Projection problems with presupposition
WebPreliminary Material. A Solution to the Projection Problem. A Solution to the Projection Problem for Presupposition. A New Semantic Computation while Parsing: Presupposition and Entailment. In Defense of the Truth Value Gap. All Time. Past Year. Past 30 Days. Abstract Views. Webprojection problem for presuppositions. (5) Someone has solved the projection problem. One way of thinking about this is to see the presupposition of the positive sentence as projected onto, and, hence, inherited by, utterances of its negative counterpart. Such projection is by no means limited to negation. Typically, utterances of interrogatives,
Projection problems with presupposition
Did you know?
Web9789004368880. Publisher: Brill. 20 Dec 1979. Morphology & Syntax. Preliminary Material. A Solution to the Projection Problem. A Solution to the Projection Problem for Presupposition. A New Semantic Computation while Parsing: Presupposition and … WebAnd more recent concern over 4 4 the projection problem" indicates ex-actly the same thing. If my dilemmatic argument is sound, there is no (interesting) projection problem. Anyone who thinks that there is a pro-jection problem must therefore be confusing semantic with "pragmatic" presupposition, even ¿/(contrary to the Kempson-Wilson-Boër ...
Webspect (e.g. presupposition), it won’t be simply true or false. Presupposition can be seen as a dimension of meaning that is characterised by two fea-tures: • Backgroundedness • Projection These two features can be used to distinguish presuppositions from at-issue meanings (alt.: assertive meanings). 1.1 Backgroundedness WebApr 1, 2011 · Projection from embeddings, especially negation, is standardly used as a diagnostic for presupposition (hence the term “negation test”). It makes sense to try several such embeddings when testing for presupposition, because it is not always clear how to apply a given embedding diagnostic.
WebDec 2, 2014 · 1 The Projection Problem of Presupposition One of the distinctive features of presuppositions is that they project. To say that presuppositions project amounts to saying that they escape from the scope of operators such as negation, modals, believe -type verbs, as well as from within the antecedent clauses of conditionals and from within questions. WebJun 1, 1971 · The notion of presupposition projection has generated a lot of interest in literature (see among others Chierchia & McConnell-Ginet, 1990;Heim, 1983, Karttunen, 1973 Langendoen & Savin, 1971;...
Webpresupposition in English, the 4 'projection problem" presents no great difficulty. It is a pseudo-problem, an artifact of early confusion over the notion of presupposition itself. Thus, whether or not one is persuaded of the Kempson-Wilson-Boër-Lycan thesis that semantic presupposition is a
WebDec 11, 2011 · This is the problem of presupposition projection. An old idea is that the presupposition of an elementary expression must be entailed by the context in which it is evaluated; the relevant notion of context is, as a first approximation, what is ‘common ground’ between the speech act participants. round farmhouse dining setWebJun 1, 2013 · Problems of projection. With the crystallization of the “generative enterprise” half a century ago, two concepts became salient: the initial state and final states of the language faculty, respectively, UG (the genetic component) and I-languages. Since then inquiry has gained far greater scope and depth. strathmeade square homeowners associationWebproblem for presupposition projection. Here we show that Karttunen’s inference-based ap-proach in his proposals from the early 1970s can be used to directly avoid the proviso problem. Inference-based projection is different from trivalent accounts or satisfaction-based methods in distinguishing presuppositions from admittance conditions on ... strathmeade hoaWeboffers a general and fully precise solution to the projection problem. Keywords: presupposition, dynamic semantics, trivalence, presupposition projection, semantics, pragmatics For the last thirty years, it has been assumed that a presupposition must be entailed (or ‘satisfied’) by the context, construed as what is common belief between the ... strath mclean daycare peterboroughWebThe problem of computing the presuppositions of complex sentences on the basis of the presuppositions of their parts is called the projection problem for presuppositions. An attractively simple attempted solution to the projection problem is: All complex sentences inherit all of the presuppositions of their parts. strathmechWebPresupposition and Anaphora: Remarks on the Formulation of the Projection Problem. Saul A. Kripke - 2009 - Linguistic Inquiry 40 (3):367-386. How Presuppositions are Inherited: A Solution to the Projection Problem. Scott Soames - 1982 - Linguistic Inquiry 13:483-545. Transparency theory and its dynamic alternatives: Commentary on “be articulate”. strath mbaWebAND THE PRESUPPOSITION PROJECTION PROBLEM Christopher Gauker University of Cincinnati 1. Introduction Contemporary work on semantic presupposition largely follows either of two schools of thought. One of these takes its lead from the work of Irene Heim (1983, 1992), who conceives of presuppositions as a kind of precondition on strathmeade square community association